I found the formula on these to be problematic. The texture reminds me more of acrylic paint than it does of nail polish. It goes on with a slight drag and has a tendency to leave bald spots and make little lumps if I'm not careful. Three coats evens out the color, and that's what I used here. A little tricky, but manageable. I found the dry time to be long on all the colors. But let me tell you about what really bothered me about the formula: applying the topcoat.
These polishes have little speckles of pigment in them (it's visible in a lot of the colors if you look closely), and they bleed when you apply topcoat. That's what gives them the color change. However, it doesn't just bleed on the nail. It bleeds into your topcoat and onto the brush. I would highly, highly recommend keeping a paper towel handy and wiping the brush before putting it back into your topcoat bottle each time. You will end up with tinted topcoat if you don't.
The other problem with topcoat application is that it streaks. If you get the nail wet enough with topcoat, the streaks tend to disappear after a while. If your coat is too thin and dries too fast, the streaks will stay.
Neither of those will be an issue if you use topcoat strictly for creating designs, which is what the intended use is. Streaks aren't visible when creating dots, for example, and you won't have tinted topcoat from using a dotting tool.
So... These are a cool idea, for sure. Can't recall seeing any other polishes like these. If you take a thin nail art brush, or a dotting tool, or even a toothpick, you can draw cool designs with topcoat. The color change isn't as obvious on the darker colors, but it's dramatic on the lighter ones.
If I was better at freehand nail art, I think I'd like these more. But, my hands are too shaky to have much success with freehand designs, and since I found the formula so strange and the topcoat bleeding problem annoying, I wasn't thrilled by these. I could use them for an easy funky french, and I tried out some dots which looked cool, but otherwise they're just a novelty for me and I don't see myself wanting to reach for them often.
(This was sent for review.)
Thanks for the swatches! You have confirmed for me that I really do not need any of these. I prefer heat-sensitive colour-changing polishes for sure.
ReplyDeleteOooh yeah the hot/cold ones are cool! Like effortless gradient mani! Gotta get me some of those! :)
DeleteOMGoodness the Modify me is such a beautiful Periwinkle, saying Periwinkle makes me happy inside!! Love it without the top coat, shame about the formula ......wondering if there is another similar colour out there??!
ReplyDeleteI bought the color called Fade into Hue, which it's the closest. I hasn't heard anything about transitions so I opted for the regular polish. So glad I did!
DeleteEssence has a few of these "Colour and Change" polishes in their product range since a few months - they work just like the China Glaze ones and they apply quite patchy, too.
ReplyDeleteApart from that; Great swatches as always! I really love your nails :)
Really cool effects! I wouldn't mind to have some of these polishes. :-)
ReplyDeleteI think I will pass on all of these as well. There are so many more interesting shades out there right now.
ReplyDeleteYay you posted!! Haha. I keep checking all the time. Anyhoo, I skipper these. I didn't see much point. If I wanna do designs or dotting, I'll just do then with another polish istead of topcoat! :P. Barry M has a collection of polishes with the same concept called Chameleon.
ReplyDeletegreat post, scrangie! i'm not feeling these either, though i always enjoy reading your reviews--totally agree that the best application would be stamping or some kind of nail art--but don't think i'm that excited about the possiblity that i'd run right out and buy these ;) still, your nails look lovely!
ReplyDeletekind of cool yet kind of meh..
ReplyDeletewhat would be some polishes strictly for like nail art use that doesnt smudge the design because i tend to smudge it when i use topcoat =/
sorry what i meant to say was what are some topcoats to use with nail art so that it doesnt smudge design lol, was obviously away there xD
DeleteI think I will stick to the Barry M ones, a lot cheaper here in the UK and by the looks of things they work a hell of a lot better! such a shame.
ReplyDeleteNot really getting all excited about these... Altough Split Perso-nail-ity with topcoat looks like a watercolor painting...kinda cool....sort off. Well, on your nails everything looks cool :)
ReplyDeleteGreat post - thanks for reinforcing that I really don't need these. I can't quite wrap my head around the point of them either. Surely you want to top coat your nails anyway? It would only be fun for nail art but even so I could easily do the same thing with 2 shades of polish?
ReplyDeleteI bought Shape Shifter, and use it for a french manicure. I like it because the top coat on the tips help to not chip it, but that's all I use it for. It does have a funny formula. Nifty idea, but not super fantastic formula. Fabulous review!
ReplyDeleteSince I almost never, ever go without a top coat (I like SHINY), these would be pretty pointless for me.
ReplyDeleteMeh, maybe if I liked the colors better I'd pick one up for the novelty factor but these are all kinda boring.
ReplyDeletewow that's disappointing! great review! completely changed my mind about getting any of these lol
ReplyDeleteI'd almost rather than they sell a tinted top coat to use with a "matched" polish. I don't like the idea of bleeding speckles! I hate it when my top coat gets color in it, but I'd buy one that already had color!
ReplyDeleteI do like Duplicity.
ReplyDeleteyea, Barry M has a few of these types of polishes, got myself one this past summer, it's an interesting idea, but really not anything special or outstanding.
ReplyDeleteThis collection seemed pretty pointless to me. You can't wear a topcoat unless you want the polish to change color, plus if I want a darker shade of the same color then I could just find the polish in that shade already.
ReplyDeleteI would love to see a french mani attempted with the Split Person-nail-ity. That could be pretty. But yes, I suppose I could just match up two shades of pink and create a french that way as well. Just convinced myself (with your review) that I don't need them...but I kinda want them anyway : )
ReplyDeleteI think this collection was just them trying to profit from a failed formulation. I don't see any appeal in a polish changing color when you put on a topcoat.
ReplyDeleteLove your blog though, thanks for posting!
Carrie, there most certainly are other shades of periwinkle out there with regular standard formulas. China Glaze has Secret Peri-Wink-Le, and Essie has several, try Lapis of Luxury. Nicole by OPI has one, and Orly has one.
ReplyDeletethese colours are amazing! and china glaze is cruelty free, which I'm trying to become. Too bad I can't find them here. I happened here by chance and really adore this blog, I hope you will come and visit mine too. i am new into nail art loving. the outlook of this site is so cool and i love your style!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteLove your blog! I hope everything is okay in Scrangie-land.
ReplyDeleteLove your blog! I hope everything is okay in Scrangie-land.
ReplyDeleteIs it sad that I check your blog every single day?...No, I don't think so..I consider it dedication to an awesome thing! Hope all is well :)
ReplyDelete