I look forward to Halloween cosmetics displays every year. I start hunting for them the minute the weather starts cooling down and usually the Fantasy Makers display is the first one out on the shelves. This year they've done a different set of colors than they have in previous years.
Creepy Pumpkin. My favorite of the bunch! I love the name, I love the color, I love the bottle... I may need a backup of this. It's a sheer orange jelly with tiny iridescent orange glass fleck glitter. Not traditional rough chunky glitter, but smooth, shiny glass fleck particles. Looks amazing on the nail. Lots of sparkle and depth because of the shiny shimmer in the jelly base.
Black Magic. This is a different version than the previous versions of Black Magic. If my eyes do not deceive me, this is simply a renamed, rebottled version of Wet n Wild Blackmail. It's a black creme base with teeny tiny multicolored microglitter. Nice and smooth, no roughness or chunkiness.
Purple Potion. Another color we've seen before; this seems like a renamed version of Wet n Wild Night Prowl. This is a black base with purple glitter. There may be a touch less glitter in Purple Potion than in Night Prowl, or just a formula inconsistency.
I didn't buy the glow in the dark polish this year because I still have two or three bottles of Night Glow from previous Halloweens. I don't go through that stuff very quickly, but it's fun to keep around. Out of all the glow in the dark polishes I've tried, I think Fantasy Makers has the brightest. It's really great, especially with the cute tombstone bottle, and it's usually under $2. It does add a sheer milky green tint to whatever polish you layer it over, so be aware of that. But it glows brightly and lasts a long time!
Good formula, good dry time, decent brushes. Pretty much the same as all the other Fantasy Makers I've used, so nothing new to report there.
I kinda wish they had done more new colors for Halloween this year, but I'm pretty happy with them otherwise. I already have Blackmail and Night Prowl (and they are two of my favorite black-based colors) so I was hoping for some different stringy glitter or even a re-release of the previous colors. But, they're good quality polishes in cute bottles, so I'm pretty content.
I got mine at Meijer, but these displays are starting to show up everywhere else as of last week. The display also has a variety of glitter products and lipsticks which are worth a look if you're into crazy holo glitter!
The orange one is amazing! Looks great on your nails.
ReplyDeleteI wasn't crazy about Creepy Pumpkin in person, but after seeing it on your nails I might have to go back and purchase it.
ReplyDeleteI'm not normally big on orange but I like the Creepy Pumpkin a lot!
ReplyDeleteI wanted the multicolored tinsel/bar glitter one but they changed it up this year. :( The orange is so pretty. Glad I got one!
ReplyDeleteYou always have great swatches!
ReplyDeleteI have all of these. I had to search through a bunch of little boxes to find Creepy Pumpkin and yesterday I got a back up!
Those look prettier than I was expecting. Love the sparkle in both. I love crazy holo glitter so I'll be on the look out for this display.
ReplyDeleteyup, you hit it right on the nose - this version of black magic is the exact same as blackmail - I just did a side by side comp on my site and they're impossible to tell apart.
ReplyDeleteHow similar is Creepy Pumpkin to Zoya's Tanzy? I love bright oranges and I love glitter but I don't want two colors that are super similar :)
ReplyDeleteDoes anybody know what other retailers sell this line? I'm like completely in love with all of them but I don't live by a Meijers at all. I've kept an eye out at Walgreens, but no dice!
ReplyDeleteFirst one is really cool. I would like to have orange like these. Perfect Halloween shade ;)
ReplyDelete@Anblick, I've seen them at ULTA and they just started showing up at the Walgreens in my area.
ReplyDeleteAll the ones labeled Black Magic at my Ulta were plain black cremes, but it did find the glitter version at Meijer. I also saw a different display at CVS that had Black Pearl (black creme) and Vamp Red (very dark burgundy creme) along with the glow in the dark (and I think the Night Prowl dupe).
ReplyDeleteI must have Creepy Pumpkin!!! Orange polish ftw!
ReplyDeleteCreepy Pumpkin I love. The other two I have from before. Now is when I start wearing orange shades.
ReplyDeleteThat orange is awesome! Gonna go on a hunt for these tomorrow. :)
ReplyDeleteI found Creepy Pumpkin to be a fussy polish to work with. I'm glad to see it done right with your post. I wasn't happy with the way my polish worked after 3 different attempts.
ReplyDeleteI am right there with you on Creepy Pumpkin. I love the name, bottle and the color!
ReplyDeleteLove these! I've seen huge displays of them where I live so I'm definitely picking them up this weekend. Hopefully I can find the glittery version of Black Magic. ^_^
ReplyDeleteMy walgreens didn't even have a spot for Creepy Pumpkin, grrrr.
ReplyDeleteThe Orange is incredible! I agree about a renamed BlackMail, and I think Purple Potion is a dupe for Mummy, May I? So... yeah. lol Great swatches!
ReplyDeletepurple potion... *dies a little*
ReplyDeleteI love the colors!!!!
ReplyDeletexoxox
Try layering a coat of Creepy Pumpkin over Black Magic and prepare yourself for multiple eyegasms!
ReplyDeleteI am in love with Creepy Pumpkin. I need it.
ReplyDelete